2012 Steelers 53 Man Roster Prediction – Post Preseason Game 2 Edition

The Pittsburgh Steelers second preseason game is now in the books and once again it is time to take another stab at a 53 man roster prediction.

Before you just jump straight to the comments, make sure to read my reasoning so you know where am I coming from on this prediction.

Two things that have really shaken things up this time around is the removal of running back Rashard Mendenhall from the PUP list and the knee injury suffered by Stevenson Sylvester. When you add both of those instances to the fact that we still do not know for sure what the status of linebackers James Harrison and Jason Worilds will ultimately be come the final cut down, it makes this exercise already harder than it normally is.

Another troubling aspect is the fact that safety Ryan Clark will not play in the opener. The Steelers must 7 players listed on the inactive list in Denver, so you really have to try to work this roster backwards from there and add in a ton of speculation.

Below is my explanation of the numbers.

Offense (23)

QB (3) – While Jerrod Johnson shows promise, I believe they will still keep Charlie Batch and sign Johnson to develop on the practice squad. Batch will be one of the inactive players in Denver.

RB (5) – Mendenhall will not be ready by the opener and thus will be inactive for that game. Baron Batch has shown enough in all areas of his game to make the roster and he can become a situational back much like Chris Rainey.

WR (4)Todd Haley very rarely uses four wide receiver sets and Rainey gives the ability to serve as a receiver should injuries strike in a game. Batch can too for that matter. David Gilreath seems to be the best of the young group right now and I have him making the practice squad and of course that could still change with two more preseason games yet to go.

FB (1)Will Johnson is the starting fullback, and because of the numbers crunch, I do not think they will carry two right now. If they do, it would likely be Jamie McCoy.

TE (2) – I really struggle here with the tight ends. The Steelers could keep two until Weslye Saunders comes back from his suspension or perhaps they keep a guy like David Paulson or Justin Peelle as a third. I am still arguing with myself on this position and getting clarity on both Harrison and Worilds will better help in this final decision.

OL (8) – Neither Trai Essex nor rookie Kelvin Beachum have earned a spot on the 53 man roster. Due to the need to carry an extra linebacker and perhaps an extra safety, I have the Steelers starting the season with 8 offensive linemen. They can do this because of the position flexibility that both Marcus Gilbert and Ramon Foster give them. Essex can wait by the phone and Beachum can be stashed on the practice squad along with undrafted free agent Ryan Lee. The Steelers normally only dress 7 offensive linemen for a game and neither Essex or Beachum are worth keeping just to put on the inactive list for the opener.

Defense (27)

NT (3) – This should be self explanatory with Steve McLendon, Casey Hampton and rookie Alameda Ta\’amu all making the 53. If Hampton is healthy for the opener, Ta\’amu will be inactive.

DE (4) – The only thing I need to figure out here is if the 4th defensive lineman will be Al Woods or Corbin Bryant. Right now I am sticking with Woods and I have Bryant making the practice squad.

ILB (5) – This is where I will upset several as I feel due to the injury to Sylvester that Brandon Johnson will make the 53. He can play both inside spots as well as outside and also contributes on special teams. Sylvester being down really helps Johnson, and like it or not, Sean Spence still has some development to do and is not ready to start.

OLB (5) – This will upset several more but I currently see the 5th outside linebacker being Mortty Ivy as he too can play both inside and outside and has been in the system for a while. In two preseason games he has received reps at both outside linebacker spots. I am not down on undrafted rookie Adrian Robinson by any means, but his lack of experience and failure to stick out thus far on special teams is what is hurting him most. The Steelers will try to get him to the practice squad, and personally I think he makes it there. Both Harrison and Worilds will not be up to full speed should they dress for the opener, so the position must have experienced depth to fall back on.

CB (5) – I just can\’t see the Steelers going into the Denver game with just 4 cornerbacks so rookie Terrence Frederick makes the roster as the 5th corner. He has been used on special teams and has played almost entirely in the preseason as the backup to Cortez Allen at the nickel spot.

S (5) – Due to Clark sitting out the opener I have Damon Cromartie-Smith making the roster still as the 5th safety. Like Robinson, I am not down on Robert Golden, but just feel that the Steelers would much rather go with Cromartie-Smith because of the time he has in the system. He can also help out on special teams in addition.

Specialist (3)

K (1) – As well as undrafted free agent kicker Danny Hrapmann has kicked thus far, I still have Shaun Suisham holding him off. Hrapmann should be available if they need him and releasing Suisham comes with dead money charges in both 2012 and 2013.

P (1)Drew Butler is winning this battle by default as Jeremy Kapinos remains sidelined after back surgery. The Steelers will be running a huge risk of carrying Kapinos into the season and he should still be available as a free agent should the rookie struggle.

LS (1) – There is no reason to think Greg Warren will be beat out by Matt Katula for the long snapper spot.

Others (10)

IR (1) – David Johnson and hopefully that is it.

SUSP (1) – Saunders and hopefully that is it.

PS (8) – This week it is Beachum, Lee, Robinson, Golden, Johnson, Bryant, Paulson and Gilreath, but this is subject to change weekly.

In conclusion, I am still unsure the most about the numbers at both the linebacker and tight end spots as well as safety. I feel good about the Steelers keeping five running backs, 8 offensive linemen and 4 wide receivers to start the season. As soon as we get more clarity on the availability of both Harrison and Worilds for the opener, it could shift a few things on my future 53 man roster predictions. My next update will be after the next game and after the Steelers trim the roster down to 80.

2012 Steelers Post Preseason Game 2 Edition 53 Man Roster Prediction

7QBBen Roethlisberger
4QBByron Leftwich
16QBCharlie Batch
34RBRashard Mendenhall
33RBIsaac Redman
27RBJonathan Dwyer
20RBBaron Batch
22RBChris Rainey
17WRMike Wallace
84WRAntonio Brown
88WREmmanuel Sanders
89WRJerricho Cotchery
53CMaurkice Pouncey
66GDavid DeCastro
73G/TRamon Foster
64G/CDoug Legursky
77TMarcus Gilbert
74GWillie Colon
78TMax Starks
76TMike Adams
83TEHeath Miller
45TELeonard Pope
46FBWill Johnson
98NTCasey Hampton
90NTSteve McLendon
95NTAlameda Ta\’amu
96DEZiggy Hood
99DEBrett Keisel
97DECameron Heyward
65DEAl Woods
24CBIke Taylor
23CBKeenan Lewis
31CBCurtis Brown
28CBCortez Allen
37CBTerrence Frederick
43SSTroy Polamalu
25FSRyan Clark
29SRyan Mundy
42SDamon Cromartie-Smith
26SWill Allen
50ILBLarry Foote
94ILBLawrence Timmons
51ILBSean Spence
93OLBJason Worilds
92OLBJames Harrison
56OLBLaMarr Woodley
55ILB/OLBStevenson Sylvester
54OLBChris Carter
48ILB/OLBBrandon Johnson
57OLB/ILBMortty Ivy
60LSGreg Warren
9PDrew Butler
6KShaun Suisham
85FBDavid Johnson
82TEWeslye Saunders
68G/TKelvin Beachum
48TEDavid Paulson
8QBJerrod Johnson
30SRobert Golden
69GRyan Lee
18WRDavid Gilreath
46OLBAdrian Robinson
91DECorbin Bryant

  • I would suggest cutting Worilds and keeping Adrian Robinson. Also, Cut Will Allen and keep Jerrod Johnson.

  • DoctorNoah

    What are the chances, you think, of Jerrod Johnson, Adrian Robinson, David Gilreath or Corbin Bryant being picked up on waivers before making the PS? How often does this happen? They’ve all performed fairly well and could arouse interest in lesser teams (the other 31).

  • Kenneth Wilt

    I think you have narrowed it down to the challenges of putting a roster together for the front office. It is no longer about…we are going to keep a certain number of players at this position or that position, it is now about which player best helps the team combined with how we cover for the injuries to the guy we really want on the field.

    As I see it we have about 14 or 15 guys fighting for the last 6 spots:

    C. Batch, J. Johnson, B. Batch,Gilreath
    Saunders, Paulson
    Essex, 1 other Olineman? Beachum or Lee…?
    Woods, Bryant
    B. Johnson, Ivy, Robinson
    Frederick, Golden, DC Smith

    Personally, I let C. Batch go for week #1. He wouldn’t play anyway. I use that roster spot temporarily to carry either an extra S or LB. Someone that can help with Harrison and Worilds out or Ryan Clark sitting game 1, and then can be cut later.

  • Koleman Dudek

    Why cut Worilds??? he is way ahead of Robinson… He will get healthy. Remember, Robinson is going against the 3rd string O-line… Imagine if Worilds went against them too…He would look dominant, Just food for thought.

  • george

    Just food for thought, Nothing against Leftwich.
    But the Steelers have done without him for the last 2 seasons. Why not cut him and keep Johnson?
    SS D. C. Smith might know the system, but he has yet to show much in preseason.
    So odds are probably 60/40 for him?
    Every year there seems to be one or two surprises.
    Where does it seem most likely this year? TE , DB , OL or LB

  • Bob

    I don’t see Robinson clearing waivers if he continues producing pressure through the last two preseason games. He may be a one trick pony at this point, he is certainly raw and benefiting from the level of competition he’s facing when he gets in, but pass rushers are such a premium commodity these days that I don’t see him getting past all 32 teams on waivers to make the practice squad.

  • ergomesh

    i doubt batch makes it i really don’t get why everyone is so high on him 1 good block in training camp last year 1 good block on touchdown last week, otherwise nothing

  • dgh57

    Why do you have Beachum on the PS?!! He hasn’t looked good this pre-season and I’ve been down on him since the draft after reading his scouting report on nfl.com!!

    J. Johnson, Golden, Gilreath, Lee, and Robinson may not clear waivers to make the PS!. At least one of these guys makes the 53 man roster because they don’t want to expose him to the waiver wire!

  • moderatelysane

    I agree. He won’t get past waivers.

  • moderatelysane

    I suspect Robinson is the only one at risk of being picked up.

  • SteelerDave

    I also see no need to keep 3 QBs. Johnson to PS and Batch or Leftwich cut making the space to be sure nobody claims Robinson.

  • Shannon Stephenson

    Even though Tony Clemons hasnt shown much I believe because we used a draft pick n him we keep him at least on the PS for a year…I believe he maybe a slow learner