James Harrison Might Need Knee Surgery According To His Agent

If you have been following my post all offseason and listening to the podcast, you know all about my level of concern regarding the health of Pittsburgh Steelers linebacker James Harrison heading into the 2012 season. That concern has been even greater ever since Harrison has failed to practice since the first week of OTA\’s due to some sort of knee problem. In fact, Harrison hasn\’t even been working on the side with the other players on the PUP list for some time now as he has been mostly relegated to working out in the weight room under the supervision of the training staff.

Mike Bires of the Beaver County Times reports Tuesday evening that knee that has been bothering Harrison might now need to be scoped and cleaned up prior to the start of the season, which by the way is less than a month away now. Bires talked to Harrison\’s agent, Bill Parise, and reports that Parise told him that the minor surgery could be forthcoming for Harrison if his knee does not respond well when he his potentially removed from the PUP list.

“With the exception of this little knee thing, James is probably healthier now that he’s been in three years,” Parise said, via the report by Bires. “He’s extremely fit. He just has to get this irritation behind his knee cap cleared up. That’s what’s causing the swelling, and (the Steelers) just want to get rid of that.”

Parise reportedly added, “So we might even look at doing a scope of that to get it cleaned up. We’ll just have to wait see how it plays out.”

Bires also reports in his story that Parise said in the interview that he thinks the Steelers right outside linebacker may be taken off the PUP list in a week or two to see how his knee responds to practice. If it doesn\’t respond well, and the swelling continues, Harrison would need the procedure done as soon as possible with hopes that he would be ready for the week 1 game against the Denver Broncos.

Another thing that everyone needs to keep in mind is that Harrison would likely miss all of the preseason as a result of the minor surgery and his practice time would be very limited; if any at all, up until the game against the Broncos. In addition, removing him from the PUP list is dangerous, because if the knee doesn\’t respond well and more recovery time is needed than initially thought, Harrison would no longer be eligible for the Reserve PUP list once he practices. You would think that merely putting him through several tough workouts on the side first, before activating from the PUP list, would be the best course of action to see how the knee responds. I of course am not a doctor though and defer to the Steelers excellent medical staff and team physicians.

I have stated a few times this offseason that I didn\’t think that Harrison would be healthy enough to play in every game this season and this knee problem certainly will not help with his ability to do that. To make matters worse, his backup Jason Worilds has yet to practice all offseason after undergoing wrist surgery. Like Harrison, Worilds remains on the PUP list and there has been no word as of yet when he will begin practicing either.

With both Harrison and Worilds sidelined, second year linebacker Chris Carter continues to take all of the first team snaps at right outside linebacker and started there this past Thursday in the Steelers first preseason game against the Philadelphia Eagles.

This is one of those occasions when I wish I was not right about something, so keep your fingers crossed that this winds up not being too serious or long-term in nature.

I am, I'm me. 40 something, retired and a life long Steelers fan.
  • HoustonJr

    Bummer. This really hurts. In my mind, a healthy Harrison & Woodley tandem is the key to producing more turnovers this year.

  • Ahmad

    So wait if he does get the surgery say next week, what would be the best estimate for him to return to the field?

  • SteelerDave

    I love Harrison’s attitude and demeanor on and off the field. The video of his car trip a while back showed the caliper of human being he truly is and that is a good guy who plays like a total beast.

    In my youth (30’s) I had played a sport at a very high level of competition and was injured and went through the exact same kind of potential surgery which is being talked about. I rehabbed and it took me three weeks before I competed again and that was too soon. In hindsight four to six weeks would have been optimal. It is a minor surgery and barring complications he should have this done now so that he rejoin us by week three of the regular season and even then play sparingly until we have our off week or simply rehab until our bye week is over.

    A person can get back to about 95% in their knee after this and so it is nothing too serious but this combined with his age will most definitely slow him down slightly even once fully recovered.

    His last season with us? I hate to say it but most likely.