Mendenhall Now Off PUP Could Mean Steelers Only Carry 4 Receivers


The removal of running back Rashard Mendenhall from the Active PUP list on Friday presents not only questions about when he will actually will be able to contribute, but also what effect it will have on the Pittsburgh Steelers final 53 man roster as well.

Now that Mendenhall has been removed from the PUP list, he can\’t go back on it, so that means he will be on the roster whether he is ready or not. Isaac Redman is currently recovering from both a groin and hip injury of some sorts, but early word is that he will be able to return to practice next week. We shall see.

Assuming Redman is healthy by week one, the Steelers also have running backs Jonathan Dwyer, Baron Batch and Chris Rainey on the roster as well. That means in all likelihood that the 53 man roster will consist of 5 running backs and at least 1 fullback in Will Johnson. In mine and most other 53 man roster predictions that you have likely seen up until this point, most have the Steelers keeping only 4 running backs with Mendenhall starting the season on the PUP list.

Now that it looks like 5 running backs will be carried, the extra roster spot will likely come via them only keeping 4 wide receivers initially, with Rainey serving as the 5th should the need arise. Face it, none of the young wide receivers have stuck out so far in training camp, so keeping the one with the most upside on the practice squad seems likely to be the plan.

Should the Steelers decide to keep 5 wide receivers as well, then the options to accommodate Mendenhall shoot off into several different directions with one of those being that they would not break camp with 5 safeties. The only reason they would consider 5 safeties on the 53 would be because Ryan Clark will sit out the week 1 game against the Denver Broncos because of his sickle cell trait. Should they decide to go with just the normal 4 with Clark of course being one them, they would be able to still accommodate a 9th linebacker on the opening 53 with both James Harrison and Jason Worilds status for week 1 in doubt.

There is still quite a ways to go before the final cut down takes place, but the addition of Mendenhall back to the roster now, certainly brings a whole new twist to how the final 53 could shake out.

One thing that crossed my mind while writing this post is that it makes you wonder if the Steelers front office now knows for certain that restricted free agent wide receiver Mike Wallace will indeed report and sign his tender prior to the start of the season. It\’s just a thought and one that we will never get an answer to.

My next 53 man roster prediction will be out following the game this Sunday against the Indianapolis Colts, and once again it will have a few more changes on it.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

About Dave Bryan

I am, I'm me. 40 something, retired and a life long Steelers fan.
  • Bob Francis

    Is there any chance they just keep 4 RBs: Mendy, Redman, Dwyer and Rainey? They could stash Barron Batch on the practice squad. I guess that leaves no obvious 3rd down back unless Rainey fills that role.

  • http://twitter.com/grw1960 george

    So far on my roster . Before Mendy’s reactivation today.
    I have been keeping Rainey KR/RB/WR on as the 5th WR
    With only 3 RBs Redman , Dwyer , B.Batch and 1 FB Will Johnson ( because of W.J’s supposedly 4.49 speed at pro day)
    But now I have to do a lot of rethinking. I don’t see any change early on at the RB roster if Mendy is not ready to play till week 3,4 or 5 of the regular season.
    What is your take?
    This is certainly a different make up.
    Would they only keep 2 TEs or 8 OL players or one less defensive player?

  • Shelob9

    Is Dwyer still eligible for the practice squad? If so why not put him there? I don’t really see what he does for us that Batch and Rainey don’t also do, but those two have more utility (3rd down, KR, etc.)

  • Itisafineday

    It’s really difficult to read what the Steelers are doing by activating Mendenhall right now. Is it simply a combination that the team truly thinks Mendenhall is coming along faster than would normally be expected? And, that their feeling a little desperate at the running back position? Especially, now that Clay is gone (although not sure if he was that valuable to the team) and Redman is banged-up. Also, Batch and Rainy have no experience under fire in real games.
    I mean, besides the physical aspects of his knee injury, football fans often hear that secondarily, a player needs time to get past the mental doubts about the injury. Mendenhall is, most likely, not going to be very effective (if at all this season) ’til sometime in the second half of this season.

If you enjoy our content & podcast, feel free to buy us a cup of coffee below.
Shop for 2012 Pittsburgh Steelers Nike and New Era Team Gear at Fanatics

Archives