2017 Midseason Player Evaluations: FS Mike Mitchell

With the Pittsburgh Steelers coming off their bye week and there soon being little to talk about in the interim outside of returning players, now would be as good a time as any to take a look back on what’s transpired this season and give out some mid-year player evaluations.

The team has had a rocky but ultimately successful season to date, coming out of the first eight games with a 6-2 record, tied for the best in the AFC along with the Patriots.

The offense has not lived up to its billing for the most part this year, though the running game has had its moments. Defensively, the sacks have come, and the secondary has improved, but there will always be things to work on.

Player: Mike Mitchell, FS

Mike Mitchell is the player you love to hate—or at least one of them. A lot of you seem to love to hate a lot of people, but Mitchell tends to be the most frequent target of late, if only because William Gay no longer sees the field frequently enough to draw as much ire as he once did.

He has, of course, been nowhere near as bad as he is frequently portrayed, but the truth is that he has not been particularly impactful on the season. He has no interceptions, no forced fumbles, and no fumble recoveries, nor sacks, and only two passes defensed. Generally, you want to get some sort of impact out of your free safety in terms of momentum-building plays. He has not delivered on that front.

But it wouldn’t be accurate to turn that into a conversation about him consistently playing poorly. A lack of big plays does not equate to an abundance of bad plays. I even attempted to write a slightly negative film room article about him and yet when people saw the plays, they defended him to me, so I don’t know what to say anymore.

He is a solid starter at worst when he is healthy. But he hasn’t been all that healthy, in spite of the fact that he has only missed one game, that coming this year. Other than the fact that he played through multiple groin tears his first year here, he hasn’t played this banged up since being in Pittsburgh.

Mitchell missed nearly all of training camp and the entirety of the preseason with a hamstring injury, and while he was able to make it back for the opener, they rotated him with J.J. Wilcox, a safety they had just acquired, in order to take some of the load off of him.

He later missed a game, and he is currently dealing with another lower body injury, which the team has described as an Achilles injury. He was limited in practice yesterday, so we will see what today’s injury report reveals. The Colts would seem to be a good opponent against which to deliver an impact play.

About the Author

Matthew Marczi

Passionate Steelers fan with a bit of writing ability. Connoisseur of loud music. Follow me on Twitter @mmarczi.

  • Charles Haines

    “A lack of big plays does not equate to an abundance of bad plays”. Sums it up perfectly.

  • Phil Brenneman II

    Can we please not say he played with 2 groin tears. It is hard to run with even 1 groin pull, there is no way he did any kind of relevant moving with 2 tears. I know that is a bit off topic but still….

    On topic he certainly isn’t having a bad season but he also isn’t really having a good one. Basically what his entire Steelers career has been. He still takes too many bad angles and misses too many tackles for my taste but still, I have come around on the POV that he does stuff off of the record as far as communication and stuff that I don’t give him enough credit for.

  • #beatthepats

    Well said Phil , I would agree.

  • nutty32

    He’s the type of guy that fans will miss when he’s gone/not playing.

  • Phil Brenneman II

    No he isn’t.

  • Mark

    I used to hammer Mike to make more plays on the ball instead of always trying to blow up the receiver. I would like for him to read the play quicker and get to the boundary. However, he has been solid and I need to pull up on Mike.

  • Mark

    Agree, his celebrations after a tackle that goes for a 1st down or long play drives me nuts. His penchant for getting 15 yard penalties and inability to make a play on the ball


    The good…apparently the staff thinks he’s been a positive veteran voice for Davis and even some of the young CBs.

    The bad…he’s just not athletic enough to make plays…he’s always a step slow or a step (now 2 steps) late to make impact plays.

    The Ugly…he’s got the 6th highest cap hit on the roster…with another yr on his contract. Fortunately, if they can land a legitimate play maker at FS…the dead money on his deal is not toxic.

  • Michael Mosgrove

    D. GRADE D.

  • Matthew Marczi

    Why is it that the only time an article about Mike Mitchell doesn’t become all about criticizing him is when we do film studies showing his play? Then all of a sudden nobody seems to have anything negative to say, and even defends him.